Managed Care Billing Fraud: 3 Signs Known Errors Are Going Uncorrected

Finding a coding error helps keep healthcare records accurate, but what happens after that finding can matter just as much. If your work involves reviewing diagnoses, handling correction requests, or checking payment data, you may see whether identified errors are actually being addressed.

Managed care billing fraud concerns can arise when unsupported diagnoses remain in data submitted to Medicare despite findings that they should be corrected. Medicare Advantage plans receive payments based partly on patients’ documented health conditions, so certain unsupported diagnoses can lead to Medicare Advantage overpayments.

The following three patterns may deserve closer review.

  1. Reviews Add Diagnoses but Leave Unsupported Codes in Place

Medical record reviews can identify supported diagnoses that were missed in an earlier submission. They may also reveal that previously submitted codes lack the required documentation.

You might notice that findings supporting higher payments move quickly through the submission process, while findings calling for code removals receive little attention. A review team may recommend both additions and removals, yet the organization submits the added diagnoses without taking the corresponding steps to remove unsupported codes. 

For example, your team might identify an unsupported condition and document why it should be removed. If that finding is repeatedly set aside while newly identified diagnoses are submitted, the difference in how findings are handled may warrant review.

Adding supported diagnoses is a normal part of accurate reporting. The concern is a process that knowingly leaves unsupported codes in place while using other findings to increase payments.

  1. Correction Requests Repeatedly Go Unanswered

You may submit a correction request with the relevant review findings, follow up with the responsible team, and receive no clear explanation of what happened next.

An unresolved request alone does not establish managed care fraud. Teams may need additional records, clarification from a provider, or time to resolve a technical issue. A documented review process with assigned responsibilities and meaningful updates can help explain a delay.

A recurring pattern may raise different questions. Requests might remain open through several review cycles, be marked complete without a corresponding correction, or move between departments without anyone taking responsibility.

Your knowledge of when an error was identified, who received the findings, and what happened afterward may help an attorney evaluate whether Medicare Advantage overpayments were knowingly retained.

  1. Staff Are Told to Leave Known Errors Unchanged

Sometimes, the concern involves a direct instruction. You may be told to disregard a review finding, stop submitting deletion requests, or retain a diagnosis even after the available documentation has been reviewed and found insufficient.

Questions may also arise when a supervisor rejects corrections because removing codes would reduce payments, without providing a valid clinical or coding explanation.

A disagreement between reviewers does not automatically mean managed care insurance fraud occurred. Coding decisions can require further assessment, and another medical record may support a diagnosis. What deserves attention is an instruction to leave an acknowledged error unchanged despite findings that support correction.

Turning Your Observations into Action

You may recognize these patterns through coding, clinical care, compliance, finance, or vendor operations. You do not need to see every submission or determine whether a law was violated before discussing what you know.

An attorney can help assess the review findings, correction process, and organization’s response. You can describe information encountered through your regular work without conducting your own investigation. Your observations may help protect Medicare funds and support accurate reporting.

Contact DJO Whistleblower Law Group for a free, confidential case review if you have seen known coding errors go uncorrected and have concerns about managed care billing fraud.

DJO operates on a contingency basis, so you won’t pay anything unless we win your case. If your case is successful, you may qualify for a reward of up to 30% of any funds recovered by the government.

 

authored by Christopher J. Piacentile
Director of Investigations DJO Whistleblower Law Group

Latest Articles